"Did UK fishermen sell their fishing rights to companies in other EU companies?
If they did, what is the injustice?"
Yep, they did. Now just like the GFA many think that it is fine to do a Trump and tear up legally binding agreements and there will be no blowback. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
 |
By *abioMan
over a year ago
Newcastle and Gateshead |
the problem is the fisherman want all the quota's back, but if that happens the EU have said if they do it they will apply tarrifs of the fish they want to sell.... and bearing in mind 80-85% of all the fish caught is sold to the EU.... that is going to cripple them!
they got greedy.... saw one side without thinking of the consequence, which is why the fishermen ended up being for brexit, but the farmers decided being against.... |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"the problem is the fisherman want all the quota's back, but if that happens the EU have said if they do it they will apply tarrifs of the fish they want to sell.... and bearing in mind 80-85% of all the fish caught is sold to the EU.... that is going to cripple them!
they got greedy.... saw one side without thinking of the consequence, which is why the fishermen ended up being for brexit, but the farmers decided being against...."
80-85% is sold to other countries thats why it is so expensive to buy here 
Eat less meat they say but they make fish more expensive |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
I'm in favour of us taking control of our coastal waters and if that means a tariff on British fish and a reduction in fish caught then so be it .I think we need to manage our fish stocks in a sustainable way and preserve what's left of our inshore fleet. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *asyuk OP Man
over a year ago
West London |
"the problem is the fisherman want all the quota's back, but if that happens the EU have said if they do it they will apply tarrifs of the fish they want to sell.... and bearing in mind 80-85% of all the fish caught is sold to the EU.... that is going to cripple them!
they got greedy.... saw one side without thinking of the consequence, which is why the fishermen ended up being for brexit, but the farmers decided being against....
80-85% is sold to other countries thats why it is so expensive to buy here
Eat less meat they say but they make fish more expensive "
You didn't address the topic though. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *asyuk OP Man
over a year ago
West London |
"I'm in favour of us taking control of our coastal waters and if that means a tariff on British fish and a reduction in fish caught then so be it .I think we need to manage our fish stocks in a sustainable way and preserve what's left of our inshore fleet."
You didn't address the topic though. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
BREXIT to restore fishing quotas eh....
"
A HUGE fuss is being made over the “betrayal” of Britain’s fishing industry with foreign boats allowed to continue harvesting our waters for 21 months after we leave the EU.
But it turns out that foreign firms already own a big slice of British fishing rights and will continue to do so permanently. Why? Because British companies sold their quotas. Spanish firms own 88 per cent of Welsh fishing rights and most of the quota from the Bristol Channel to the Scottish border.
Dutch and Icelandic firms control most of our East Coast fishing. European seas are split into sectors and governments hand out quotas specifying how much of each type of fish can be caught. Unlike in other countries the Environment Department allows any or all of its quotas to be sold to foreign trawler firms.
“England and Wales have mismanaged their fishing quota and Brexit will do nothing to put it right,” says law lecturer Tom Appleby.
The fishing industry has largely gone the way of so much of British business, manufacturing and utilities that have been sold off to Chinese, American and other foreign investors with the approval of successive governments.
No use moaning about it now because the family silver has long gone in return for a quick but one-off profit.
"
So, the question is.... how does BREXIT fix this ? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"BREXIT to restore fishing quotas eh....
A HUGE fuss is being made over the “betrayal” of Britain’s fishing industry with foreign boats allowed to continue harvesting our waters for 21 months after we leave the EU.
But it turns out that foreign firms already own a big slice of British fishing rights and will continue to do so permanently. Why? Because British companies sold their quotas. Spanish firms own 88 per cent of Welsh fishing rights and most of the quota from the Bristol Channel to the Scottish border.
Dutch and Icelandic firms control most of our East Coast fishing. European seas are split into sectors and governments hand out quotas specifying how much of each type of fish can be caught. Unlike in other countries the Environment Department allows any or all of its quotas to be sold to foreign trawler firms.
“England and Wales have mismanaged their fishing quota and Brexit will do nothing to put it right,” says law lecturer Tom Appleby.
The fishing industry has largely gone the way of so much of British business, manufacturing and utilities that have been sold off to Chinese, American and other foreign investors with the approval of successive governments.
No use moaning about it now because the family silver has long gone in return for a quick but one-off profit.
So, the question is.... how does BREXIT fix this ?"
It's the British way - how we can make money easily.
They probably think that once we leave they can re-sell to someone else?
Anyay that's what Del would do isn't it? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *mmabluTV/TS
over a year ago
upton wirral |
"the problem is the fisherman want all the quota's back, but if that happens the EU have said if they do it they will apply tarrifs of the fish they want to sell.... and bearing in mind 80-85% of all the fish caught is sold to the EU.... that is going to cripple them!
they got greedy.... saw one side without thinking of the consequence, which is why the fishermen ended up being for brexit, but the farmers decided being against....
80-85% is sold to other countries thats why it is so expensive to buy here
Eat less meat they say but they make fish more expensive "
So true I am eating more fish and food bill goes up |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *mmabluTV/TS
over a year ago
upton wirral |
"BREXIT to restore fishing quotas eh....
A HUGE fuss is being made over the “betrayal” of Britain’s fishing industry with foreign boats allowed to continue harvesting our waters for 21 months after we leave the EU.
But it turns out that foreign firms already own a big slice of British fishing rights and will continue to do so permanently. Why? Because British companies sold their quotas. Spanish firms own 88 per cent of Welsh fishing rights and most of the quota from the Bristol Channel to the Scottish border.
Dutch and Icelandic firms control most of our East Coast fishing. European seas are split into sectors and governments hand out quotas specifying how much of each type of fish can be caught. Unlike in other countries the Environment Department allows any or all of its quotas to be sold to foreign trawler firms.
“England and Wales have mismanaged their fishing quota and Brexit will do nothing to put it right,” says law lecturer Tom Appleby.
The fishing industry has largely gone the way of so much of British business, manufacturing and utilities that have been sold off to Chinese, American and other foreign investors with the approval of successive governments.
No use moaning about it now because the family silver has long gone in return for a quick but one-off profit.
So, the question is.... how does BREXIT fix this ?"
Ask someone in the fishing industry they voted out so they must have reasons |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"BREXIT to restore fishing quotas eh....
A HUGE fuss is being made over the “betrayal” of Britain’s fishing industry with foreign boats allowed to continue harvesting our waters for 21 months after we leave the EU.
But it turns out that foreign firms already own a big slice of British fishing rights and will continue to do so permanently. Why? Because British companies sold their quotas. Spanish firms own 88 per cent of Welsh fishing rights and most of the quota from the Bristol Channel to the Scottish border.
Dutch and Icelandic firms control most of our East Coast fishing. European seas are split into sectors and governments hand out quotas specifying how much of each type of fish can be caught. Unlike in other countries the Environment Department allows any or all of its quotas to be sold to foreign trawler firms.
“England and Wales have mismanaged their fishing quota and Brexit will do nothing to put it right,” says law lecturer Tom Appleby.
The fishing industry has largely gone the way of so much of British business, manufacturing and utilities that have been sold off to Chinese, American and other foreign investors with the approval of successive governments.
No use moaning about it now because the family silver has long gone in return for a quick but one-off profit.
So, the question is.... how does BREXIT fix this ?Ask someone in the fishing industry they voted out so they must have reasons"
I read recently that there are just 3 companies that control the lion's share of the UK market (something like 80%) ? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *asyuk OP Man
over a year ago
West London |
"BREXIT to restore fishing quotas eh....
A HUGE fuss is being made over the “betrayal” of Britain’s fishing industry with foreign boats allowed to continue harvesting our waters for 21 months after we leave the EU.
But it turns out that foreign firms already own a big slice of British fishing rights and will continue to do so permanently. Why? Because British companies sold their quotas. Spanish firms own 88 per cent of Welsh fishing rights and most of the quota from the Bristol Channel to the Scottish border.
Dutch and Icelandic firms control most of our East Coast fishing. European seas are split into sectors and governments hand out quotas specifying how much of each type of fish can be caught. Unlike in other countries the Environment Department allows any or all of its quotas to be sold to foreign trawler firms.
“England and Wales have mismanaged their fishing quota and Brexit will do nothing to put it right,” says law lecturer Tom Appleby.
The fishing industry has largely gone the way of so much of British business, manufacturing and utilities that have been sold off to Chinese, American and other foreign investors with the approval of successive governments.
No use moaning about it now because the family silver has long gone in return for a quick but one-off profit.
So, the question is.... how does BREXIT fix this ?Ask someone in the fishing industry they voted out so they must have reasons"
Have you thought about answering the question yet? You've been given half of it 
To be fair you're the only Brexit supporter even able to post it seems.
Did UK fishermen sell their fishing rights to companies in other EU companies?
If they did, what is the injustice? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
The fishing rights should never have belonged to individual fishermen, if that was the case it was wrong. Our waters belong to us, and after BREXIT should be fished by our fishermen only. The government should charge a licence fee, and with the exception of anglers using rods and lines, anyone fishing our waters should own one.
We do eat a lot of fish in this country, unfortunately we are buying fish caught in our waters by foreign trawlers and sold back to us cheaper than those currently on offer from our own fleets. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *ara JTV/TS
over a year ago
Bristol East |
Seriously?
You gonna let an entire species migrate to Britain and not even check if they are entitled to be here?
You know they bring crabs and cod knows what else with them.
And those bottom-feeders among them are, well . . . eeeeeew!
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *asyuk OP Man
over a year ago
West London |
"The fishing rights should never have belonged to individual fishermen, if that was the case it was wrong. Our waters belong to us, and after BREXIT should be fished by our fishermen only. The government should charge a licence fee, and with the exception of anglers using rods and lines, anyone fishing our waters should own one.
We do eat a lot of fish in this country, unfortunately we are buying fish caught in our waters by foreign trawlers and sold back to us cheaper than those currently on offer from our own fleets."
Was it the fault of the EU if the UK government chose to exercise its sovereignty by allocating fishing rights in this manner?
Should the EU have prevented us from doing so?
Are you upset that the majority of fish landed by UK owned vessels is sold abroad? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Seriously?
You gonna let an entire species migrate to Britain and not even check if they are entitled to be here?
You know they bring crabs and cod knows what else with them.
And those bottom-feeders among them are, well . . . eeeeeew!
"
We've even started getting tuna turning up a little further to the west and I can guarantee they are not European like the French bass that cruise our shores looking to pick off our local fish for lunch.
I did my bit for brexit and took a few yesterday .  |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Did UK fishermen sell their fishing rights to companies in other EU companies?
If they did, what is the injustice?"
We are better in the EFTA as not part of EU fisheries or common agricultural policy.
Brexit for all
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *asyuk OP Man
over a year ago
West London |
"Did UK fishermen sell their fishing rights to companies in other EU companies?
If they did, what is the injustice?
We are better in the EFTA as not part of EU fisheries or common agricultural policy.
Brexit for all
"
Did UK fishermen sell their fishing rights to companies in other EU companies?
If they did, what is the injustice? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
» Add a new message to this topic
