 |
By *irldnCouple
over a year ago
Brighton |
Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World! |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *ackal1Couple
over a year ago
Manchester |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!"
Ya communist leftie !!! Fuck the citizens of this country I want an island in the Caribbean and a new Lear Jet thanks!!
It’s called trickle down economics I just love the way all that lovely wonga trickles constantly into my offshore accounts .
Do you not know your place? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!"
How much profit a year did British Gas make when it was state owned? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!
How much profit a year did British Gas make when it was state owned?"
Government owned organisations are not set up to make profit. If they do it is displayed as a reduced running cost and the Government simply reduces their funding and spends the surplus Tax money elsewhere. Governments NEVER admit thet took more tax than they needed. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!
Ya communist leftie !!! Fuck the citizens of this country I want an island in the Caribbean and a new Lear Jet thanks!!
It’s called trickle down economics I just love the way all that lovely wonga trickles constantly into my offshore accounts .
Do you not know your place? "
Did not have Thatcher down as a lefty she sold British Gas.
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!
How much profit a year did British Gas make when it was state owned?"
It did not make big profit fa's was just cheaper. But there was also a lot of wastage in the company. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *irldnCouple
over a year ago
Brighton |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!
How much profit a year did British Gas make when it was state owned?"
It’s quite sweet that people think Centrica’s profits are because it is better run or somesuch! Price gauging. War profiteering. Whatever it is, consumers lose. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *ackal1Couple
over a year ago
Manchester |
Profits drive efficiencies in many industries a lack of accountability is what can make national industries less efficient.
I would still wager even with that efficiency disparity that as a nation and consumers we would have been better off had the utilities stayed in state ownership.
Revenues not dished out as dividends would have been reinvested or used to reduce customer charges . Either way it would have been better .
Remember in many cases these organisations were run by the same employees and directors both sides of the fence of private and state.
The skill set was the same . Greed changed it when accountability could have without the loss to us all. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *ackal1Couple
over a year ago
Manchester |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!
Ya communist leftie !!! Fuck the citizens of this country I want an island in the Caribbean and a new Lear Jet thanks!!
It’s called trickle down economics I just love the way all that lovely wonga trickles constantly into my offshore accounts .
Do you not know your place?
Did not have Thatcher down as a lefty she sold British Gas.
"
Did you read what the OP said ?
I think you’ve got the wrong end of the stick!  |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *otMe66Man
over a year ago
Terra Firma |
"Thatcher sold British gas now its making money the government want some of the profit back.
Is that fair."
I would like to discuss the fairness of shareholders losing their holdings once the government takes back control, that would mean we took the right action.
I've never had strong feelings for state controlled /owned anything, but surely everyone and I mean everyone, can see the benefits of taking it back. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *ackal1Couple
over a year ago
Manchester |
"Thatcher sold British gas now its making money the government want some of the profit back.
Is that fair.
I would like to discuss the fairness of shareholders losing their holdings once the government takes back control, that would mean we took the right action.
I've never had strong feelings for state controlled /owned anything, but surely everyone and I mean everyone, can see the benefits of taking it back."
Interesting point as weren’t a lot of state shares given away or at least discounted to customers and institutions to get them sold? Maybe I’m remembering building societies too much?? Happy to be corrected .
I do believe core utilities and infrastructure should never have been sold. It has deprived the country of its basic wealth . |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *otMe66Man
over a year ago
Terra Firma |
"Thatcher sold British gas now its making money the government want some of the profit back.
Is that fair.
I would like to discuss the fairness of shareholders losing their holdings once the government takes back control, that would mean we took the right action.
I've never had strong feelings for state controlled /owned anything, but surely everyone and I mean everyone, can see the benefits of taking it back.
Interesting point as weren’t a lot of state shares given away or at least discounted to customers and institutions to get them sold? Maybe I’m remembering building societies too much?? Happy to be corrected .
I do believe core utilities and infrastructure should never have been sold. It has deprived the country of its basic wealth . "
You wont hear me say this often, I totally agree with you   |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Imagine if it was state owned. All that profit for the benefit of all citizens by boosting the coffers of HMT! Or alternatively they could have kept prices down for consumers and made less profit. Either way it would have been a win for the people of the UK rather than shareholders around the World!
Ya communist leftie !!! Fuck the citizens of this country I want an island in the Caribbean and a new Lear Jet thanks!!
It’s called trickle down economics I just love the way all that lovely wonga trickles constantly into my offshore accounts .
Do you not know your place?
Did not have Thatcher down as a lefty she sold British Gas.
Did you read what the OP said ?
I think you’ve got the wrong end of the stick! "
Foster can I thank you for this comment.
And as you point out if it was still state owed and pricing reduced we would all be spending more on other things improving GDP and growth for the Country.
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Thatcher sold British gas now its making money the government want some of the profit back.
Is that fair.
I would like to discuss the fairness of shareholders losing their holdings once the government takes back control, that would mean we took the right action.
I've never had strong feelings for state controlled /owned anything, but surely everyone and I mean everyone, can see the benefits of taking it back."
Guess it would just be buy back if shears where sold for a pound when floted they where sold. And are now worth just short of £106 so thats the price the UK PLC would need to pay. Shere holders would take there cash and invest in something else. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Thatcher sold British gas now its making money the government want some of the profit back.
Is that fair.
I would like to discuss the fairness of shareholders losing their holdings once the government takes back control, that would mean we took the right action.
I've never had strong feelings for state controlled /owned anything, but surely everyone and I mean everyone, can see the benefits of taking it back.
Interesting point as weren’t a lot of state shares given away or at least discounted to customers and institutions to get them sold? Maybe I’m remembering building societies too much?? Happy to be corrected .
I do believe core utilities and infrastructure should never have been sold. It has deprived the country of its basic wealth . "
No your right my father work for British Gas he was given 2 shears for each year he had worked for them an could buy shears for a pound. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Thatcher sold British gas now its making money the government want some of the profit back.
Is that fair.
I would like to discuss the fairness of shareholders losing their holdings once the government takes back control, that would mean we took the right action.
I've never had strong feelings for state controlled /owned anything, but surely everyone and I mean everyone, can see the benefits of taking it back.
Guess it would just be buy back if shears where sold for a pound when floted they where sold. And are now worth just short of £106 so thats the price the UK PLC would need to pay. Shere holders would take there cash and invest in something else. "
UK plc would not have to pay a penny, UK plc just restarts nationalised enerrgy to attract customers who want nationalised energy. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Consumers in the UK pay the highest rate for utilities in the World. IN THE WORLD! You have your own natural gas. Start setting up fracking wells. "
Exactly, we have it here but too many people object. However they are quite happy to use it when it's shipped over the pond.! |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Thatcher sold British gas now its making money the government want some of the profit back.
Is that fair.
I would like to discuss the fairness of shareholders losing their holdings once the government takes back control, that would mean we took the right action.
I've never had strong feelings for state controlled /owned anything, but surely everyone and I mean everyone, can see the benefits of taking it back.
Guess it would just be buy back if shears where sold for a pound when floted they where sold. And are now worth just short of £106 so thats the price the UK PLC would need to pay. Shere holders would take there cash and invest in something else.
UK plc would not have to pay a penny, UK plc just restarts nationalised enerrgy to attract customers who want nationalised energy. "
UK Plc fracking gas.
Cheap gas owned by the state.
I wait for the objections! |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
You can cite free enterprise until the cows come home but when one specific industry is reaping massive profits you have to at least consider slapping a fat tax on them.
At the moment literally everyone else, the typical individual, government departments, and all other companies are feeling the pain of high energy prices.
At the very least mandate that money is invested into green energy supply, more windmills and tide machines. (We think nuclear is the best compromise though). |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
» Add a new message to this topic
