I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
 |
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?"
The only country that cared about adhering to EU rules was the UK. That's why we ended up leaving. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
The only country that cared about adhering to EU rules was the UK. That's why we ended up leaving."
I'm sure there are those who would agree, just as there are more vocal individuals who would not |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?"
I would guess they can stop ppl they believe don't have a valid Schengen visa. Or are smuggling such.
It also seemed to be at least some of the argument is around law of the sea. Which isn't an EU rule.
Similar to us trying to not apply other treqtiea we sign up to.
Countries, like people, tens to push laws as far as they can on their favour. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?"
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns?"
I have no idea |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *eroy1000Man
over a year ago
milton keynes |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns?
I have no idea "
I don't know for sure either but would imagine there are certain circumstances where they can close boarders. If that is the case then just depends on if this falls into the allowed circumstances. This situation could be repeated as the Italian new leaders campaigned on addressing their immigration concerns. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns?
I have no idea "
They did. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns?
I have no idea
They did. "
But not to those claiming asylum or for other humanitarian issues |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns?
I have no idea
They did.
But not to those claiming asylum or for other humanitarian issues "
Honestly, not sure. They closed their borders to eachother though. So it's definitely possible. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns?
I have no idea
They did.
But not to those claiming asylum or for other humanitarian issues
Honestly, not sure. They closed their borders to eachother though. So it's definitely possible. "
Asylum and humanitarian were exceptions |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I read today of a "disagreement" between the two over the issue of immigration. Italy refusing to allow a rescue ship to dock in their waters and announcing that France would accept them before France announced it. Now being reported that France is implementing border checks and controls with Italy. I didn't think shengen or the EU charter allowed this? Am I wrong?
Didn't they all close their borders during the initial covid lockdowns?
I have no idea
They did.
But not to those claiming asylum or for other humanitarian issues
Honestly, not sure. They closed their borders to eachother though. So it's definitely possible.
Asylum and humanitarian were exceptions"
 |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
» Add a new message to this topic
