FabSwingers.com > Forums > The Lounge > Eldely should do community work or lose pension
Eldely should do community work or lose pension
Jump to: Newest in thread
In my _iew this guy should be sectioned under the mental health act.
Lord Bichard, an ex-chief of the Benefits Agency, said the elderly should get rewards and fines to make sure they are taking a more active part in the world.
This was taken from the Telegraph. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
 |
By *dwalu2Couple
over a year ago
Bristol |
But it's a very sensible proposal. If you work a pensioner into an early grave, not only will they contribute to the economy, but also save the country money on pension and infrastructure provision. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"In my _iew this guy should be sectioned under the mental health act.
Lord Bichard, an ex-chief of the Benefits Agency, said the elderly should get rewards and fines to make sure they are taking a more active part in the world.
This was taken from the Telegraph."
My grandad worked from 14-75.. I think he was active enough for long enough  |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *dwalu2Couple
over a year ago
Bristol |
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same"
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
"
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
Well, that took some chasing down!
Story is from 2012, is one man's (ex Brent Council leader) suggestion to a committee, his _iews were widely dismissed as nonsense, and the chap concerned was made a peer by Gordon Brown.
Still, good to see the facts still aren't getting in the way of political discussions/scaremongering on here
Mr ddc |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *dwalu2Couple
over a year ago
Bristol |
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts"
No, the country absolutely can afford to keep people for so many years after retirement. We can also afford to pay nurses a living wage, to build decent schools, to give yopung people housing benefits, and a million other things that we supposedly can't afford to do.
We are a RICH country. We CHOOSE, instead of doing those other things, to subsidise wars in other countries, to subsidise tax breaks for the wealthy, to artificially push house prices up, to purchase redundant nuclear deterrents.
So, in short, we choose to be an ugly society, rather than a decent one. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
If there were any coal mines left, we could get them hauling the coal. Save on the cost of looking after the ponies.
No reason why they could not work at McDonalds.
Or, alternatively, we could accept that we too will retire one day with dignity and a well-deserved desire to be cared for. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"And every work shy drug taker and alcoholic can sit on their arse doing f/all"
Walk in a drug adicts shoes for a week
Most wish to be different
It's easy to think these people have a choice
But in reality many do not
And I was almost murdered by one
So I wasn't a fan
But now I am a volunteer with adicts to help them get back to a life that's better for them |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"i think the pension should be means tested.
also, those that live permanently abroad, should not get a pension at all
(grabs tin hat and hides) "
Do people who no longer live in this country get a UK state pension? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
At least when i retire at 67 (prob more by that time) i know i've done my bit and paid for my own pension to live comfortable more than can be said for a lot of people,why i sometimes work 48hr weeks to pay them. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts"
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!! |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
"
And would take jobs away from the yoof who are desperately seeking hard work to get themselves off benefits and out of ladbrooks and pubs. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"i think the pension should be means tested.
also, those that live permanently abroad, should not get a pension at all
(grabs tin hat and hides)
Do people who no longer live in this country get a UK state pension? "
yes, all the retired ex pats get full pensions |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!"
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"i think the pension should be means tested.
also, those that live permanently abroad, should not get a pension at all
(grabs tin hat and hides)
Do people who no longer live in this country get a UK state pension? "
If they paid into the system all their lives while working I dont see why they shouldn't.. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"i think the pension should be means tested.
also, those that live permanently abroad, should not get a pension at all
(grabs tin hat and hides)
Do people who no longer live in this country get a UK state pension?
If they paid into the system all their lives while working I dont see why they shouldn't.. "
 |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
I left school at 16, I can draw state pension at 66, that's FIFTY years I will have been contributing, I only hope I live until 106 years, then I'll be a pensioner longer than a worker |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?"
Under 18s draw pension do they? Wow and I thought their parents kept them |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!"
Blimey that was a very bitchy and hostile people on these forums are just getting so nasty lately
Now re read what I actually out, I said you have worked for less years than you have not worked
Think about i won't hold my breath for an apology
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?
Under 18s draw pension do they? Wow and I thought their parents kept them"
Your just going out your way to be rude to people now |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?
Under 18s draw pension do they? Wow and I thought their parents kept them"
Child benefit? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?
Under 18s draw pension do they? Wow and I thought their parents kept them"
She didn't say they Drew pensions.. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?
Under 18s draw pension do they? Wow and I thought their parents kept them
Child benefit?"
Nobody mentioned what benefits you get I simple said if you start work and 18 and retire at 60 you have worked for less years than you have no worked
Which you do if you live into your 90
Some just come on here looking for stuff to pick on its a bit tedious
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?
Under 18s draw pension do they? Wow and I thought their parents kept them
Child benefit?"
My parents got six shillings a week for me and my father paid that back in tax. Are you really comparing child benefit which is taxed now to the state pension? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?"
Well pedantically yes, but do many paper rounds come with a final salary scheme? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"But it's a very sensible proposal. If you work a pensioner into an early grave, not only will they contribute to the economy, but also save the country money on pension and infrastructure provision."
Raise retirement age to 75 then make them do 50 hours a week community service. Oldies don't sleep much and there's sod all on the telly. They'll love it. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
You forgot the 18 years not working before they started. Add to 30 yrs after = 48. 18 to 60 working is 42. So nothing wrong with their maths, or mine. Check your own?
Under 18s draw pension do they? Wow and I thought their parents kept them
Child benefit?
Nobody mentioned what benefits you get I simple said if you start work and 18 and retire at 60 you have worked for less years than you have no worked
Which you do if you live into your 90
Some just come on here looking for stuff to pick on its a bit tedious
"
So I should just accept someone telling me that paying into my state pension for 50 years doesn't entitle me to draw a pension without working for it. I wish I had paid into a personal pension for that long, I would be laughing.
BTW the average life expectancy for a woman in the UK currently is 82.5 years. So I can draw my state pension for 16.5 years, woop de woo!!! |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *andy_tomMan
over a year ago
wolverhampton |
"In my _iew this guy should be sectioned under the mental health act.
Lord Bichard, an ex-chief of the Benefits Agency, said the elderly should get rewards and fines to make sure they are taking a more active part in the world.
This was taken from the Telegraph."
there keeping the undertakers happy , as they cant live on there pension, in the winter times they have to choose betwean eating or heating ,  |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I think everyone on JSA should have to do community work to entitle them to the benefit. "
Can't do that as they say you can't be looking for work while doing other things.. I wanted to go back to college to do a fitness trainer/gym instructor course in September when my lad starts at school but was told that if I did that I wouldn't be able to claim benefit as I wouldn't be looking for work (even though it was only a 2 day a week course) |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"I think everyone on JSA should have to do community work to entitle them to the benefit.
Can't do that as they say you can't be looking for work while doing other things.. I wanted to go back to college to do a fitness trainer/gym instructor course in September when my lad starts at school but was told that if I did that I wouldn't be able to claim benefit as I wouldn't be looking for work (even though it was only a 2 day a week course) "
That's shitty |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"I think everyone on JSA should have to do community work to entitle them to the benefit.
Can't do that as they say you can't be looking for work while doing other things.. I wanted to go back to college to do a fitness trainer/gym instructor course in September when my lad starts at school but was told that if I did that I wouldn't be able to claim benefit as I wouldn't be looking for work (even though it was only a 2 day a week course) "
That's absolutely ridiculous!!! When do they think working people look for other jobs?!! In their pissing spare time, evenings/weekends etc. who the hell spends 9-5 Monday to Friday looking for work?! They could do community work 9-12, one hour lunch, then 1-4 job hunting!?  |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Nobody mentioned what benefits you get I simple said if you start work and 18 and retire at 60 you have worked for less years than you have no worked
Which you do if you live into your 90"
Where did you get 60 as state retirement age? The current age is 65, gradually increasing for the next thirty years.
It has been 65 for men since state pensions were introduced in 1948 |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
"I think everyone on JSA should have to do community work to entitle them to the benefit.
Can't do that as they say you can't be looking for work while doing other things.. I wanted to go back to college to do a fitness trainer/gym instructor course in September when my lad starts at school but was told that if I did that I wouldn't be able to claim benefit as I wouldn't be looking for work (even though it was only a 2 day a week course)
That's absolutely ridiculous!!! When do they think working people look for other jobs?!! In their pissing spare time, evenings/weekends etc. who the hell spends 9-5 Monday to Friday looking for work?! They could do community work 9-12, one hour lunch, then 1-4 job hunting!? "
I know! So now instead of training for a career Im going back to my part time dead end job serving people sausage rolls and cheese!
I think the other argument I saw somwhere once as well was that if they were getting the unemployed to work doing these jobs then people that actually got paid to do them would gradually see their hours drop where companies tried to cut wages as they could get JSA claimants to work for free. Like council gardeners, street cleaners, that sort of thing. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Depends on the ability of the person not everyone ages the same
Some might also say that having worked all their lives, expecting pensioners to return to work in order that they not starve to death is perhaps a touch cruel.
The thing is people don't work all their lives anymore do they?
When pensions were set at 60 most people didn't live much past that now days there are more people over 85 in the uk than under 16 years old, everyone's living longer, but people still want to retire at 60/65 while a hell of a lot are living into their 90s, now days if you leave school at 18 and work till your 60 yet live till your 90 you have actually worked for less years that you have not worked and the country simply can not afford to keep people for so many years after retirement
So retirement ages go up and you have to keep yourself for longer if you want to live longer
I'm not saying I agree with making old people work but they are the simple facts
My God your maths needs some sorting!!!!! 18-60 is forty two years of contributing. 60-90 I'd only 30 of drawing pension. So they are not simple facts!!!!
Blimey that was a very bitchy and hostile people on these forums are just getting so nasty lately
Now re read what I actually out, I said you have worked for less years than you have not worked
Think about i won't hold my breath for an apology
"
you are basing that on made up figures. I started work at 16, I can draw state pension at 66, life expectancy for me is 82.5 years. I will pay in for 50 years, 16 years not working as a child and 16.5 drawing a pension, that's 32.5 years not working. Making up your own figures and calling them facts is the problem here, not that I pointed out the error |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Well, that took some chasing down!
Story is from 2012, is one man's (ex Brent Council leader) suggestion to a committee, his _iews were widely dismissed as nonsense, and the chap concerned was made a peer by Gordon Brown.
Still, good to see the facts still aren't getting in the way of political discussions/scaremongering on here
Mr ddc"
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Well, that took some chasing down!
Story is from 2012, is one man's (ex Brent Council leader) suggestion to a committee, his _iews were widely dismissed as nonsense, and the chap concerned was made a peer by Gordon Brown.
Still, good to see the facts still aren't getting in the way of political discussions/scaremongering on here
Mr ddc
"
As always the most sensible post on a thread by far got lost in a barrage of people shouting out their (often misguided) _iews on both sides |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"Well, that took some chasing down!
Story is from 2012, is one man's (ex Brent Council leader) suggestion to a committee, his _iews were widely dismissed as nonsense, and the chap concerned was made a peer by Gordon Brown.
Still, good to see the facts still aren't getting in the way of political discussions/scaremongering on here
Mr ddc
As always the most sensible post on a thread by far got lost in a barrage of people shouting out their (often misguided) _iews on both sides "
That's entirely what the forums are for silly, taking some obscure bit of news and blowing it up, completely obscuring the context, adding in a few anomalous "facts" of our own and then stomping off in a huff |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"i think the pension should be means tested.
also, those that live permanently abroad, should not get a pension at all
(grabs tin hat and hides)
Do people who no longer live in this country get a UK state pension?
yes, all the retired ex pats get full pensions"
Not strictly correct. In most cases they do but there is the odd weird anomaly.
IIRC certain places eg civilised Canada of all places, ex-pat pensioners do not get the full, if indeed any, annual increase in pensions. Yet many do. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"i think the pension should be means tested.
also, those that live permanently abroad, should not get a pension at all
(grabs tin hat and hides)
Do people who no longer live in this country get a UK state pension?
yes, all the retired ex pats get full pensions"
That they have paid into whilst working!!! Why should something you have paid for be means tested? Feckless, lazy arsed fuckers who sit on their arses all day doing fuck all will still 'retire' with a modest level of income because of means tested benefits. However you are suggesting they should be treated the same as people who have grafted all their lives?
Yes we have an ageing population and if people want to work past retirement age that should be a personal choice. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *icketysplitsWoman
over a year ago
Way over Yonder, that's where I'm bound |
"Pensioners HAVE contributed ffs  "
All of them? 
It was a daft article from years ago.
Have a look at the Centre for Ageing Better. They are more holistic but keeping active through working in some way (voluntary or paid) is part of their remit.
|
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
Pensioners do not get back pound for pound what they paid in - they get more and that difference has to be paid by someone.
I always chuckle when I hear a pensioner talk about stopping benefits for other people.
If someone worked for an average salary or below during 40s, 50s, 60s & 70s - they wouldn't pay in ten years what they now get out in one year when you add in the inflated pension, winter fuel payments, assissted living payments and TV license.
If the government can cut benefit payments and have the full expectation that people can live off that then why can't pensioners take a cut too?
And not all pensioners have worked all of their lives. I don't know why they should be treated any differently to anyone else. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
And when they brought out sanctions for the unemployed, we knew they'd go for the disabled too, and they did. We said it'd be the pensioners next.
Doesn't anybody learn anything from what they did last time they were in? They put up the state pension by 10p so that pensioners lost their income support and that was worth £30.
They'll do it. Guaranteed. Suprised they told anyone before the election though.
Vote Conservative "do the right thing" lol. Your lives have no value to them, they don't care unless they're making money off you, they are fucked in the head, all of them. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
They don't need to cut pensions looking at half the comments in here actually.
Instead of forming something positive where the pensions can't be cut, say protest or petition or anything, look at all the comments saying take from someone else instead. Look at how your treating other human beings- who have nothing to do with this decision by the way -treating them like they deserve nothing and should be taken from.
Well how shit are some humans really? They can rationalise anything evil enough when they want to. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
Stop taking from those who had nothing in the first place! Stop taking from ALL vulnerable, don't just pick and choose who loses everything and who doesn't, ffs...
Improve humanity by being compassionate and being a good example to future generations and don't let the few run our lives, and your lives, because politicians and all these kaisers don't live in our circles, they don't have to put up with all the social after effects of these cuts - we do. Or am i living in a hell bubble where theft crime only went up round here, and violence has gone up, and people are going hungry? |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"It's because of disabled transgender immigrants. I read it on a leaflet the local MP shoved through the door. I'm voting for him. "
I'm voting for him to be put naked in a pit and to be allowed to be stoned by pensioners. I suspect he would come out without any votes but unharmed. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By *oole2010Couple
over a year ago
southampto |
"Nobody mentioned what benefits you get I simple said if you start work and 18 and retire at 60 you have worked for less years than you have no worked
Which you do if you live into your 90
Where did you get 60 as state retirement age? The current age is 65, gradually increasing for the next thirty years.
It has been 65 for men since state pensions were introduced in 1948 "
Yep thats right and it was based on the fact that about 47 percent of the population died before reaching that age Now its just 16 percent hence raising the retirement age so we can die before claiming
And thats what all successive governments banked on they apent all the extra cash that should have been put away |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
|
By (user no longer on site)
over a year ago
|
"I think everyone on JSA should have to do community work to entitle them to the benefit.
Can't do that as they say you can't be looking for work while doing other things.. I wanted to go back to college to do a fitness trainer/gym instructor course in September when my lad starts at school but was told that if I did that I wouldn't be able to claim benefit as I wouldn't be looking for work (even though it was only a 2 day a week course)
That's absolutely ridiculous!!! When do they think working people look for other jobs?!! In their pissing spare time, evenings/weekends etc. who the hell spends 9-5 Monday to Friday looking for work?! They could do community work 9-12, one hour lunch, then 1-4 job hunting!? "
If you're on JSA you have to spend (and prove you did this) 40 hours a week looking for work, or do 'job training' schemes (which is basically work you don't get paid for). Or you get sanctioned. |
Reply privately, Reply in forum +quote
or View forums list | |
» Add a new message to this topic
