FabSwingers.com > Forums > The Lounge > Take the knee?
Jump to: Newest in thread
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"We? Support our black citizens - yes." Absolutely! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? " A more apt question would be, why should people not take the knee, and until the answer is clear with no dissent of those who are discriminated against then it should continue. Still do not understand why people object, it can only be because it pricks an unconscious, or conscious, bias. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? A more apt question would be, why should people not take the knee, and until the answer is clear with no dissent of those who are discriminated against then it should continue. Still do not understand why people object, it can only be because it pricks an unconscious, or conscious, bias." Well said! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"Has the issue been resolved? " This | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee!" This | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"We? Support our black citizens - yes." It's about all racism | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
" Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing" That's like saying don't mention crashes at a road safety lecture. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee!" Why not? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly!" So you support the right of players to take the knee if they want to? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I think it’s personal choice, I have nothing against players or teams decisions on it. " This | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing" So we should just ignore it and it will go away? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly!" I guess we should also stop looking to cure cancer as well then? (And they aren't going down on one knee on the telly. It's in a huge football stadium which happens to get on the telly). Gbat | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly!" Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No, my reasoning is that you don't bow down or kneel down to racism bullying and the such like. You Stand up to racism and bullying. So I would much rather see teams STAND in a line link arms and stand in solidarity against racism and bullying. " I like this a lot | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away?" Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other... | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two" It's a sad fact that Black people are disproportionately attacked by the justice system. When White people get the same treatment, they will get people taking the knee for them. When Black people get the same treatment as White people, you can stop making gestures of solidarity as they will no longer be needed. Gbat | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"Yes. It’s not enough to just say you’re not racist. Things need to change to more people being actively anti racist. " Yes. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No, my reasoning is that you don't bow down or kneel down to racism bullying and the such like. You Stand up to racism and bullying. So I would much rather see teams STAND in a line link arms and stand in solidarity against racism and bullying. I like this a lot " Thank you | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No, my reasoning is that you don't bow down or kneel down to racism bullying and the such like. You Stand up to racism and bullying. So I would much rather see teams STAND in a line link arms and stand in solidarity against racism and bullying. " Surely it doesn't matter how players highglight racism? Taking a gesture popularised by Martin Luther King is surely a fitting way to do it? Plus, it's not really a great look for white people to be telling people of colour how to protest against the racism that they are suffering. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"Has the issue been resolved? " Yesssss THIS | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away? Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other..." Why can't we do both? I realise that it makes some people feel uncomfortable to highlight the racism that is going on in our society but who are we, as white people, to tell people of colour how to protest against the racism that they, not us, are suffering? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No, my reasoning is that you don't bow down or kneel down to racism bullying and the such like. You Stand up to racism and bullying. So I would much rather see teams STAND in a line link arms and stand in solidarity against racism and bullying. Surely it doesn't matter how players highglight racism? Taking a gesture popularised by Martin Luther King is surely a fitting way to do it? Plus, it's not really a great look for white people to be telling people of colour how to protest against the racism that they are suffering." Exactly. The essence of what they are saying is ‘highlight the racism you experience in a way that is more performatively acceptable to me, and easier to ignore for others’. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? " While racism is endemic absolutely. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away? Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other... Why can't we do both? I realise that it makes some people feel uncomfortable to highlight the racism that is going on in our society but who are we, as white people, to tell people of colour how to protest against the racism that they, not us, are suffering?" As I stated "I read a comment" I'm not in any way racist nor do I agree with how people are treated. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away? Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other... Why can't we do both? I realise that it makes some people feel uncomfortable to highlight the racism that is going on in our society but who are we, as white people, to tell people of colour how to protest against the racism that they, not us, are suffering? As I stated "I read a comment" I'm not in any way racist nor do I agree with how people are treated. " I didn't say you were racist but what you seemed to be saying is that you didn't agree with footballers highlighting that racism is a problem in this country (and elsewhere). | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I find blm divisive and way to political...and so much anger seems to surround it on both sides. I would prefer a message or symbol looking to the future.. where we are humanity and together we stand side by side no matter colour, sexual identity or gender (or vaccine status!). In my mind im colour blind your either a good person or your a not. " Are you white? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee!" I see what you've done there | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! So you support the right of players to take the knee if they want to?" If they want to do it then crack on, but it all seems to be a little forced. If my team mate took the knee beside me and I just started randomly warming up for the game by doing star jumps, I'd be deemed a racist. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"together we stand side by side no matter [ ... ] vaccine status!. " You were doing okay until this point. Your vaccine status might have a devastating effect on my families health! Gbat | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good " How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"Yes. It’s not enough to just say you’re not racist. Things need to change to more people being actively anti racist. Yes. " Yes they should continue until the message penetrates the general population. Which will be a long time. Decades, if not longer. Bad ideas take a long time to dissipate and even then, can resurface. Him x | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! " Unsurprisingly, no-one has ever interpreted it this way. So not ironic at all is the answer. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? " Just wondering if any changes came with it in the end? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"If the players still want to then yes. Is the act making a difference? It seems after the abuse our English players received the answer is no. Would a stronger act have more affect? Would leaving the pitch get a better outcome? I realise that it is not everyone that is racist and if the game were to stop then it would affect the none racists but action needs to bd more? If the players were fully backed by clubs and the association by acting strongly then would this work better? All just questions …. But more is needed … the powers that be need to act too " A team recently left a football pitch in protest "Olympic football team have walked off the pitch during a friendly against Honduras after alleged racial abuse directed at their player Jordan Torunarigha." You can do all sorts to show your support against racism. I like the idea of linking arms, too. It is not one gesture over another - anything that will highlight racism is fine with me. Just because racism is still alive, it does not mean we stop trying. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! " Personally, I see the kneeling just as a sign of respect and humility towards any human. I do not see it as being submissive at all. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"If the players still want to then yes. Is the act making a difference? It seems after the abuse our English players received the answer is no. Would a stronger act have more affect? Would leaving the pitch get a better outcome? I realise that it is not everyone that is racist and if the game were to stop then it would affect the none racists but action needs to bd more? If the players were fully backed by clubs and the association by acting strongly then would this work better? All just questions …. But more is needed … the powers that be need to act too A team recently left a football pitch in protest "Olympic football team have walked off the pitch during a friendly against Honduras after alleged racial abuse directed at their player Jordan Torunarigha." You can do all sorts to show your support against racism. I like the idea of linking arms, too. It is not one gesture over another - anything that will highlight racism is fine with me. Just because racism is still alive, it does not mean we stop trying." Very much agreed … but if stronger acts like walking off the pitch were to affect others I.e those at the game then maybe those who aren’t racists will call out the racists…which will assist those to identify the racists and haul them out the ground with a lifetime ban | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? Just wondering if any changes came with it in the end?" It caused nationwide dialogue about the racism that still exists in this country, caused many to consider whether they were contributing to that existence, and many more to publicly make it known they stand against racism who would otherwise never have done so. So there was a positive change. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! " Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee!" Why shouldn't they take the knee, and why is it bothering you? That's the real question | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee! Why shouldn't they take the knee, and why is it bothering you? That's the real question " In a nutshell! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee! Why shouldn't they take the knee, and why is it bothering you? That's the real question " I think this may have been sarcasm. I could be wrong though | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act." I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I'd take a knee for my black brothers" I really need to start checking before I post | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee! Why shouldn't they take the knee, and why is it bothering you? That's the real question " I think it's great that footballers taking the knee to highlight the issue of racism is making people uncomfortable. Hopefully it will enable people to take the next step and ask themselves the questions you are talking about. We are all biased subconsciously about one thing or another, it's only by being able toi admit it that we are able to work on it and become better people. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. " You seem to be very confused. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. " Do hospitals promote illness? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. " I had not thought of the kneeling gesture in that way but perhaps it is. So if a stain on humanity like racism, is not being stopped by gestures then what hope is there for the non-white communities? And what hope would there have been for the LGBT communities... and many others, naming just two as an example. I believe change starts with small positive gestures and educating people. How else would you suggest there is any hope for change? Genuine question. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. Do hospitals promote illness?" No but the government and pharmaceutical companies do! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? Just wondering if any changes came with it in the end? It caused nationwide dialogue about the racism that still exists in this country, caused many to consider whether they were contributing to that existence, and many more to publicly make it known they stand against racism who would otherwise never have done so. So there was a positive change." I stood in rally's carrying big boards stating racial discrimination - that was the 80's... Did the knee have more of an impact, change the minds of the abusive ones..... can't see that on other media platforms ... | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
" I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. " Well if nothing is going to stop racism we might as well just give up then and accept it. And its HIGHLIGHTING not promoting | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. I had not thought of the kneeling gesture in that way but perhaps it is. So if a stain on humanity like racism, is not being stopped by gestures then what hope is there for the non-white communities? And what hope would there have been for the LGBT communities... and many others, naming just two as an example. I believe change starts with small positive gestures and educating people. How else would you suggest there is any hope for change? Genuine question. " It needs to be taught better in schools and it needs to be shown that it's not just non whites that receive race hate. Races need to be able to mix more rather than sticking to their "own kind" and in communities. As long as older generations of racists still exist, there will always be an element of racism at home. Racism will never fully stop but it just might calm down a little | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. Do hospitals promote illness? No but the government and pharmaceutical companies do!" But death is inevitable and curing illnesses is just pointless, all hospitals are doing are literally promoting illnbess by trying to do something about it. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? " We? You are a professional footballer? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. I had not thought of the kneeling gesture in that way but perhaps it is. So if a stain on humanity like racism, is not being stopped by gestures then what hope is there for the non-white communities? And what hope would there have been for the LGBT communities... and many others, naming just two as an example. I believe change starts with small positive gestures and educating people. How else would you suggest there is any hope for change? Genuine question. It needs to be taught better in schools and it needs to be shown that it's not just non whites that receive race hate. Races need to be able to mix more rather than sticking to their "own kind" and in communities. As long as older generations of racists still exist, there will always be an element of racism at home. Racism will never fully stop but it just might calm down a little" Understand what you are saying - at work we have Anti bias training at least once a year, it focusses on skin colour but also on other issues such as LGTB, sexism, ageism etc. It is quite effective as it makes (most) people think. There are some "die-hards" who refuse to acknowledge that we do not live in a perfect society though. I agree with you on education at an early age, before prejudices can be internalised and become hard-wired in the young brain, for sure! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. I had not thought of the kneeling gesture in that way but perhaps it is. So if a stain on humanity like racism, is not being stopped by gestures then what hope is there for the non-white communities? And what hope would there have been for the LGBT communities... and many others, naming just two as an example. I believe change starts with small positive gestures and educating people. How else would you suggest there is any hope for change? Genuine question. It needs to be taught better in schools and it needs to be shown that it's not just non whites that receive race hate. Races need to be able to mix more rather than sticking to their "own kind" and in communities. As long as older generations of racists still exist, there will always be an element of racism at home. Racism will never fully stop but it just might calm down a little Understand what you are saying - at work we have Anti bias training at least once a year, it focusses on skin colour but also on other issues such as LGTB, sexism, ageism etc. It is quite effective as it makes (most) people think. There are some "die-hards" who refuse to acknowledge that we do not live in a perfect society though. I agree with you on education at an early age, before prejudices can be internalised and become hard-wired in the young brain, for sure!" You're correct regarding education but it also needs parents are in board too and that is where the problem. We are not born racist, it is something that children hear and witness. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
" I agree with you on education at an early age, before prejudices can be internalised and become hard-wired in the young brain, for sure! You're correct regarding education but it also needs parents are in board too and that is where the problem. We are not born racist, it is something that children hear and witness. " ABsolutely agree with you - parents have perhaps the most crucial role. I am just thinking that a child that grows up in a racist environment at home, at least has the change to challenge the thinking when they are getting a more humane message from school. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. I had not thought of the kneeling gesture in that way but perhaps it is. So if a stain on humanity like racism, is not being stopped by gestures then what hope is there for the non-white communities? And what hope would there have been for the LGBT communities... and many others, naming just two as an example. I believe change starts with small positive gestures and educating people. How else would you suggest there is any hope for change? Genuine question. It needs to be taught better in schools and it needs to be shown that it's not just non whites that receive race hate. Races need to be able to mix more rather than sticking to their "own kind" and in communities. As long as older generations of racists still exist, there will always be an element of racism at home. Racism will never fully stop but it just might calm down a little Understand what you are saying - at work we have Anti bias training at least once a year, it focusses on skin colour but also on other issues such as LGTB, sexism, ageism etc. It is quite effective as it makes (most) people think. There are some "die-hards" who refuse to acknowledge that we do not live in a perfect society though. I agree with you on education at an early age, before prejudices can be internalised and become hard-wired in the young brain, for sure! You're correct regarding education but it also needs parents are in board too and that is where the problem. We are not born racist, it is something that children hear and witness. " And that's why it will always be around. The same goes for educating children on historical events such as sla very. This will forever anger the minds of our next generation | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"As long as there are people, there will be racism. Bit of awareness doesn’t hurt anyone, I guess, particularly as football tends to appeal to the shittier people." Just curious: Why/ how are football fans "shittier people"? How are "they" different to Rugby, tennis etc fans? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No It's a waste of time and energy. Racism will never stop, no matter what. People are free to do what they want but a racist isn't going to change their views just because some people go down on one knee on the telly! Taking the knee may not change a racist today, however it sends a message to the younger generations that racism is not to be tolerated. The message delivered by people of influence is changing attitudes today and going forward it is what I believe is needed to end racism. People of influence, influencing for good How is taking the knee showing it wont be tolerated? You're literally kneeling in front of the racists. You're kneeling before them like you're surrendering! How ironic is that?! Not ironic at all because this is not Game of Thrones and people don't see taking the knee as a submissive act. I actually thought that the kneeling was because Mr Floyd was knelt on! They can do it however they like. Go marching, take a knee on national telly, they can write something on the moon for all I care. Nothing and I repeat "NOTHING" will ever stop racism happening. They are literally promoting racism. I had not thought of the kneeling gesture in that way but perhaps it is. So if a stain on humanity like racism, is not being stopped by gestures then what hope is there for the non-white communities? And what hope would there have been for the LGBT communities... and many others, naming just two as an example. I believe change starts with small positive gestures and educating people. How else would you suggest there is any hope for change? Genuine question. It needs to be taught better in schools and it needs to be shown that it's not just non whites that receive race hate. Races need to be able to mix more rather than sticking to their "own kind" and in communities. As long as older generations of racists still exist, there will always be an element of racism at home. Racism will never fully stop but it just might calm down a little Understand what you are saying - at work we have Anti bias training at least once a year, it focusses on skin colour but also on other issues such as LGTB, sexism, ageism etc. It is quite effective as it makes (most) people think. There are some "die-hards" who refuse to acknowledge that we do not live in a perfect society though. I agree with you on education at an early age, before prejudices can be internalised and become hard-wired in the young brain, for sure! You're correct regarding education but it also needs parents are in board too and that is where the problem. We are not born racist, it is something that children hear and witness. " This with the parents... | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No. Ita about as much use as the "clap" for the NHS and carers. What good did that do...???" 100% agree with that | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away? Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other..." Sick and fucking tired of the false equivalency! We wouldn’t take the knee for the white community because they haven’t endured hundreds of years of racism. Seriously, go get a clue! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No. Ita about as much use as the "clap" for the NHS and carers. What good did that do...???" Maybe it's the players showing solidarity with their own friends and team mates who have suffered racial abuse on the pitch. They may not be able to do much to change things, but want to show their support. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee! Why shouldn't they take the knee, and why is it bothering you? That's the real question " You have read this wrong I think the OP means there shouldn’t be a need for any of us to take the knee, there shouldn’t be any racism or any differences between any of us, racism has no place in today’s multi-cultured society, this is my take on it. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"Has the issue been resolved? " The perfect answer! In our view, if taking the knee causes you offence then you don’t understand the issue and are also part of the problem! One planet, one human race, with equality for all! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away? Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other... Sick and fucking tired of the false equivalency! We wouldn’t take the knee for the white community because they haven’t endured hundreds of years of racism. Seriously, go get a clue! " Yes they have. It's just not highlighted nearly as much | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away? Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other... Sick and fucking tired of the false equivalency! We wouldn’t take the knee for the white community because they haven’t endured hundreds of years of racism. Seriously, go get a clue! " | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No one should be taking a knee! Why shouldn't they take the knee, and why is it bothering you? That's the real question You have read this wrong I think the OP means there shouldn’t be a need for any of us to take the knee, there shouldn’t be any racism or any differences between any of us, racism has no place in today’s multi-cultured society, this is my take on it. " That is how I interpreted it, too. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"Has the issue been resolved? The perfect answer! In our view, if taking the knee causes you offence then you don’t understand the issue and are also part of the problem! One planet, one human race, with equality for all!" Love the last statement - sums it up beautifully. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"I read a comment somewhere that stated taking the knee for our black community is only highlighting the fact...you wouldn't take the knee for our white community....why it's just creating a bigger split between the two Imho we are all human regardless of colour sex or anything else so should treat everyone the same anyway Teaching racism by highlighting it is not a good thing So we should just ignore it and it will go away? Not at all...I'm saying support and educate in a way that doesn't highlight it as being different for one and not the other... Sick and fucking tired of the false equivalency! We wouldn’t take the knee for the white community because they haven’t endured hundreds of years of racism. Seriously, go get a clue! Yes they have. It's just not highlighted nearly as much" | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
| |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"So as the new football season is about to kick off,should we still be taking the knee? " No but I do think they need to do something to remind everyone that we all still have a massive problem and we need to keep progressing. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"Has the issue been resolved? The perfect answer! In our view, if taking the knee causes you offence then you don’t understand the issue and are also part of the problem! One planet, one human race, with equality for all!" That's your opinion. In mine you don't solve one issue by creating a new issue. There's plenty still to do... But there's many ways to raise awareness and demonstrate solidarity to a cause. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"As long as there are people, there will be racism. Bit of awareness doesn’t hurt anyone, I guess, particularly as football tends to appeal to the shittier people. Just curious: Why/ how are football fans "shittier people"? How are "they" different to Rugby, tennis etc fans? " Literally just because football is the more popular sport and therefore will have a bigger minority of idiots. Non-football fans just like to tar us all with the same brush though | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"It's not the sentiment people are objecting to, it's the gesture and the fact that it was imported into the UK on the back of the BLM riots After what happened in London last summer its almost absurd to expect people not to boo" Even though the players have explicitly said it’s nothing to do with the BLM political movement? It’s almost as if you’re looking for a reason to justify disliking people being anti-racist. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"As long as there are people, there will be racism. Bit of awareness doesn’t hurt anyone, I guess, particularly as football tends to appeal to the shittier people. Just curious: Why/ how are football fans "shittier people"? How are "they" different to Rugby, tennis etc fans? Literally just because football is the more popular sport and therefore will have a bigger minority of idiots. Non-football fans just like to tar us all with the same brush though" Well also.. You don't get tennis rugby etc fans breaking into stadia and shirting in cups in the stands... | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"It's not the sentiment people are objecting to, it's the gesture and the fact that it was imported into the UK on the back of the BLM riots After what happened in London last summer its almost absurd to expect people not to boo Even though the players have explicitly said it’s nothing to do with the BLM political movement? It’s almost as if you’re looking for a reason to justify disliking people being anti-racist." The players can say what they like. Its ridiculous to suddenly expect people not to associate taking the knee with BLM riots and the extreme left politics of the BLM organisation | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"It's not the sentiment people are objecting to, it's the gesture and the fact that it was imported into the UK on the back of the BLM riots After what happened in London last summer its almost absurd to expect people not to boo Even though the players have explicitly said it’s nothing to do with the BLM political movement? It’s almost as if you’re looking for a reason to justify disliking people being anti-racist. The players can say what they like. Its ridiculous to suddenly expect people not to associate taking the knee with BLM riots and the extreme left politics of the BLM organisation " It's also not necessary. With a bit of imagination they could make a gesture that is more positive uplifting impactful engaging less controversial. It should absolutely not be about drawing battle lines and insulting people for their opinions and labelling anyone who doesn't join in an enemy and part of any problem. We can apply some thought and do something better. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"It's not the sentiment people are objecting to, it's the gesture and the fact that it was imported into the UK on the back of the BLM riots After what happened in London last summer its almost absurd to expect people not to boo Even though the players have explicitly said it’s nothing to do with the BLM political movement? It’s almost as if you’re looking for a reason to justify disliking people being anti-racist. The players can say what they like. Its ridiculous to suddenly expect people not to associate taking the knee with BLM riots and the extreme left politics of the BLM organisation " Why? I don't associate it with the BLM political movement or riots. The players have stated that it isn't and that's enough for me. Do you think people are unable to comprehend what they are being told byu the players or do you think they are choosing to ignore it because it makes it easier for them boo people who are making an anti-racism statement? Which of course leads to the question what sort of person would boo someone making an anti-racist statement? | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"It's not the sentiment people are objecting to, it's the gesture and the fact that it was imported into the UK on the back of the BLM riots After what happened in London last summer its almost absurd to expect people not to boo Even though the players have explicitly said it’s nothing to do with the BLM political movement? It’s almost as if you’re looking for a reason to justify disliking people being anti-racist. The players can say what they like. Its ridiculous to suddenly expect people not to associate taking the knee with BLM riots and the extreme left politics of the BLM organisation It's also not necessary. With a bit of imagination they could make a gesture that is more positive uplifting impactful engaging less controversial. It should absolutely not be about drawing battle lines and insulting people for their opinions and labelling anyone who doesn't join in an enemy and part of any problem. We can apply some thought and do something better. " I'm not sure a white person telling people of colour how to protest against racism is as anti-racist as you perhaps think it is. | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"It's not the sentiment people are objecting to, it's the gesture and the fact that it was imported into the UK on the back of the BLM riots After what happened in London last summer its almost absurd to expect people not to boo Even though the players have explicitly said it’s nothing to do with the BLM political movement? It’s almost as if you’re looking for a reason to justify disliking people being anti-racist. The players can say what they like. Its ridiculous to suddenly expect people not to associate taking the knee with BLM riots and the extreme left politics of the BLM organisation It's also not necessary. With a bit of imagination they could make a gesture that is more positive uplifting impactful engaging less controversial. It should absolutely not be about drawing battle lines and insulting people for their opinions and labelling anyone who doesn't join in an enemy and part of any problem. We can apply some thought and do something better. " Exactly. The linking of arms was met by cheers. This is why I say its not the sentiment that people are against it's that particular gesture and its associations to rioting and hard left politics | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"No. Ita about as much use as the "clap" for the NHS and carers. What good did that do...???" It sent a message, loud and clear, to a government that has spent a decade reducing the funding to the NHS, that it’s people expected and supported more. 3% is better than 1% but still far off what it should be! | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |
"It's not the sentiment people are objecting to, it's the gesture and the fact that it was imported into the UK on the back of the BLM riots After what happened in London last summer its almost absurd to expect people not to boo Even though the players have explicitly said it’s nothing to do with the BLM political movement? It’s almost as if you’re looking for a reason to justify disliking people being anti-racist. The players can say what they like. Its ridiculous to suddenly expect people not to associate taking the knee with BLM riots and the extreme left politics of the BLM organisation Why? I don't associate it with the BLM political movement or riots. The players have stated that it isn't and that's enough for me. Do you think people are unable to comprehend what they are being told byu the players or do you think they are choosing to ignore it because it makes it easier for them boo people who are making an anti-racism statement? Which of course leads to the question what sort of person would boo someone making an anti-racist statement?" Well good for you but I'm afraid that's exactly what people booing do appear to associate it with. And they have good reason By your reasoning the players could walk on the pitch and give a Nazi salute and it would be ok as long as they said it had nothing to do with 1930s German fascism | |||
Reply privately (thread closed by moderator) |